Would everyone like USB-C on the Teensy 4.1?

dgdimick

Member
What does everyone think about replacing the Micro-USB connector with USB-C on a future Teensy 4.1 revision?

I’m using Teensy 4.1 boards for three DCS cockpit radio projects. A reversible connector would make connecting cables behind the panels easier, and USB-C cables are becoming more common in my workshop.

Would this be useful for your projects too? Are there reasons you’d prefer to keep Micro-USB?
 
Here's what I would rather have
1. USB be actual pins on the board. that way I can put a usb jack directly on my PCB's and wire it to the Teensy. I need this for easier field (re)programming. Right now i have to design PCB such that the Teensy usb is near the edge so I can plug a cable through the case into the Teensy
2. Extend a 4.0 by 2-3 pins per side--I don't need all the pins of a 4.1 but the USB RxTx and a few more GPIO pins.
 
Well yes, you have my vote. But I suppose that would have to be a completely new version to support all of the C features
 
Normally I don't talk of future products, but in this case I'll just say "we're looking at this". I can't promise a date or details.

I can say only Teensy 4.1 has room for a USB-C connector. It simply can not fit on Teensy 4.0.

When (not if, but when) a USB-C version of Teensy 4.1 arrives, don't expect anything fancy like PD support. It'll almost certainly be the simple way with two 5.1K pulldown resistors.
 
I need this for easier field (re)programming. Right now i have to design PCB such that the Teensy usb is near the edge
I must confess I’ve never fully understood this approach. If the Teensy USB is damaged due to over-use or an inept user, it’s game over. Plus my use cases often need access to the SD slot.

On the rare occasions I enclose a Teensy, I’ll usually put in a short USB extension to a panel-mounted socket, which can be changed out in case of damage. That leaves the possibility to put an SD access on the outside - fiddly, but doable.
 
I must confess I’ve never fully understood this approach. If the Teensy USB is damaged due to over-use or an inept user, it’s game over. Plus my use cases often need access to the SD slot.

On the rare occasions I enclose a Teensy, I’ll usually put in a short USB extension to a panel-mounted socket, which can be changed out in case of damage. That leaves the possibility to put an SD access on the outside - fiddly, but doable.
My two cents worth, my application(s) use the pins in sockets teensy 4.1, so I prefer to simply replace the teensy for updating the program and I avoid the usb for any user interaction, as there are lots of other communication options.
 
It'll almost certainly be the simple way with two 5.1K pulldown resistors.
I've mentioned this before but I would find it very inconvenient if the onboard port lost the ability to function as a host, which it would with these pulldowns in place.
 
What would you recommend instead?
A way to disable the pulldowns (like cuttable links) would be enough for me. Or at the least position them so they could be relatively easily unsoldered without disturbing anything else.
 
Last edited:
I've mentioned this before but I would find it very inconvenient if the onboard port lost the ability to function as a host, which it would with these pulldowns in place.
Just to make sure I'm understanding this, are you saying that the micro USB port can function as a host? I thought it was peripheral only.
 
Just to make sure I'm understanding this, are you saying that the micro USB port can function as a host? I thought it was peripheral only.
It works fine as a host with an OTG adapter (especially handy for using USB devices with the T4.0).

Using a USB-C to USB-A adapter would probably work around the pulldown problem, but half the attraction of having a USB-C port directly on the board would be being able to directly connect USB-C devices...
 
Last edited:
Which specific USB devices won't work? Most just connect pulldown resistors to their own CC pins.
I don't know enough about the differences between a USB-A connection versus a full USB-C connection and what new capabilities might be possible with the T4.1.

For example, with a USB-C connection, could could one hook up something like:

I purchased one of these to hook up to an Arduino UNO Q, which allowed one to hook up a display, keyboard, mouse... And boot up that board directly...

Recently I noticed that you can plug this in to an Portenta H7 (Actually some of the tutorials mentions using a USB to HDMI cable), but I thought I would give it a try.

And it worked(1024x768). For the heck of it I converted the GIGA version of the weather display stuff
1793542049271.png

Currently sort of a pain to play with as, currently I have to unplug the adapter, and plug it back into USB to update the program...
And I don't currently have any easy way to do input to the program to for example click on Wed to see that days details...
But it was just an experiment.

My guess is their other boards with this same processor (STM32H747) can do this as it looks like the H7 uses a more complicated USB-C connection (something like 24 pins):
1793542649415.png

Where as the GIGA, like some of their other boards use ones with fewer pins like:
1793542729224.png


It would be fun to see what all we could do with a Teensy!
 
Which specific USB devices won't work? Most just connect pulldown resistors to their own CC pins.
Smartphones. Most of them can act as either a device or host but if they sense fixed pulldowns they will not switch to device role (and won't offer it as a choice to the user).
 
We're probably on a path to USB-C device mode only for future Teensy 4.1 (but of course the 5-pin host port will remain the same). It's not just the CC pins. The VIN-VUSB jumper pads and the through-hole VUSB pad on Teensy 4.1 with Micro-B simply can't fit when the larger USB-C connector is used. The current plan is looking like an "ideal diode" chip, which should be much more convenient for people wanting to supply external power while still using USB device mode. But power output from USB-C would be another obstacle if you want to use the 1st USB port for host mode.

It's easy to think of just replacing the Micro-B connector with USB-C connector. But aside the practical reality turns out to be a bit more complicated...
 
We're probably on a path to USB-C device mode only for future Teensy 4.1 (but of course the 5-pin host port will remain the same). It's not just the CC pins. The VIN-VUSB jumper pads and the through-hole VUSB pad on Teensy 4.1 with Micro-B simply can't fit when the larger USB-C connector is used. The current plan is looking like an "ideal diode" chip, which should be much more convenient for people wanting to supply external power while still using USB device mode. But power output from USB-C would be another obstacle if you want to use the 1st USB port for host mode.

It's easy to think of just replacing the Micro-B connector with USB-C connector. But aside the practical reality turns out to be a bit more complicated...
Thanks for the reply, Paul. I didn’t think my question would throw a grenade into the room! Now that you and others have explained what’s involved, I can see there’s a lot more to it than just swapping the connector.

Whenever a USB-C Teensy comes along, I’ll happily buy one just to have it sitting around to play with.

The suggestions about using an adapter cable or a panel-mount extension have been really helpful, and I’ll follow that advice for my project.

Thanks to everyone who chimed in and helped me understand the issues.

Denis
 
I'd like to see a small daughterboard for USB programming. Something that can snap on and off like a UFS module, with small flat surface-mount connectors. That way, you can implement a simple USB-C connector with resistors for basic programming, or later add a more advanced board that supports PD.
 
Back
Top